55% of Callers Less Likely to Buy When AI Answers the Phone

Yousif Alias · 4 min read

55% of Callers Less Likely to Buy When AI Answers the Phone

What did the new AI phone survey find?

In a survey released November 19, 2026, 55% of consumers said they are less likely to become a customer when a business uses AI instead of people to answer its phones. The survey covered 6,000 adults in the US, UK and Canada and was run by OnePoll for AnswerConnect.

The numbers come from AnswerConnect's 2026 AI Customer Experience Survey, fielded in May 2026 and split evenly across the three countries. CX Today reported the same headline figures the next day. The rest of the findings point the same way:

FindingResultLast year
Less likely to become a customer when AI answers55%Not reported
Find AI agents frustrating when calling customer service59%54%
Would hang up if connected to AI31%29%
Say AI support rarely or never solves their problem34%Not reported
Feel their time was wasted explaining the problem to AI before a transfer36%Not reported
Leave a review after a good call with a person vs. with AI55% vs. 8%Not reported

Frustration and hang-ups both rose from last year, so callers are getting less patient with bad phone bots as they meet more of them.

Who ran the survey, and should you trust it?

AnswerConnect sells human receptionist services, so it has a reason to publish a survey that makes AI look bad. CX Today said so in its own write-up. The sample is still large, the polling was done by an outside firm, and the questions were repeated from last year, so the trend lines are comparable.

We build and sell AI voice agents at KenjiAI, so this is one vendor commenting on another vendor's data. Neither of us is neutral. What's worth your time is the list of things callers say they hate.

The release describes a recorded call in which an AI sales agent reached a human receptionist, confirmed it was AI, and then asked her how it could help. It had called her and didn't know why. AnswerConnect CEO Natalie Ruiz put it this way in the release: "The AI in this call couldn't do the one thing a person does without thinking: know why they're calling."

Why do callers hang up on AI agents?

Callers hang up when the AI can't solve the problem, makes them repeat themselves, or traps them before they reach a person. In this survey, 34% said AI support rarely or never resolves their issue and 36% felt their time was wasted explaining things to AI before being transferred.

Every one of those complaints traces back to setup. An agent that doesn't know the business, can't book the appointment, and hands the caller to a human with no notes will lose the sale. A human receptionist who did the same thing would lose it too.

People were almost seven times more likely to leave a review after a good call with a person (55%) than after one with AI (8%). If your phone line is where happy customers get handled, and nobody there asks for a review, you're giving away the easiest reviews you'll ever get.

What should a business that answers leads by phone do now?

Keep AI on the jobs it does well, like answering every call fast, booking, and covering after hours, and make the handoff to a person instant and painless. Then ask for reviews from the conversations people actually liked. Use this checklist before you put any agent on your main line:

  1. Give the agent one clear job per call type: book the estimate, answer hours and pricing questions, or take a message. Don't let it guess.
  2. Let the caller reach a human the moment they ask. One request should be enough.
  3. Pass the full call summary to whoever picks up, so the caller never explains the problem twice. That one fix goes straight at the 36% figure.
  4. Have the agent say plainly that it's an AI assistant if someone asks. Dodging the question costs more trust than the answer does.
  5. Send a review request by text after the appointment or after a good call with your team, not in the middle of an AI exchange. Our guide on getting more Google reviews on autopilot covers the timing.
  6. Listen to ten recorded calls a week. If callers are hanging up at the same spot, fix that line in the script.

The alternative most small businesses actually have is voicemail, not a full-time receptionist. If you want to see what the unanswered calls are costing you before you decide anything, run your numbers through our free missed call calculator.

At KenjiAI we set up Voice AI agents to answer, qualify and book, with a warm transfer to your team when a caller wants a person and the call notes already in your CRM. Review requests go out by text and email after the job, so the people who had a good experience are the ones you ask.

What does this mean if you run ads?

If you pay for clicks or calls, a bad phone experience burns that spend at the last step. A caller who hangs up on a confused bot is a lead you already paid for. Track hang-ups and transfers from paid calls separately so you can see whether the phone line is losing what the ads bought.

Most ad dashboards stop counting at the call. Tag your call tracking numbers by campaign, then compare booked appointments against calls, not clicks against calls. If one campaign's callers hang up more, the ad is probably fine and the answering setup needs fixing first.

Frequently asked questions

What percentage of consumers are less likely to buy when AI answers the phone?

In AnswerConnect's 2026 AI Customer Experience Survey, released November 19, 2026, 55% of consumers said they are less likely to become a customer when a business uses AI instead of people to answer calls. OnePoll surveyed 6,000 adults in the US, UK and Canada in May 2026.

Are AI phone agents getting more or less popular with callers?

Less popular, according to this survey. 59% of respondents found AI agents frustrating when calling customer service, up from 54% the year before, and 31% said they would hang up if connected to AI, up from 29%. The complaints center on unresolved problems and having to repeat themselves.

Should a small business stop using an AI receptionist?

Not necessarily. The survey's complaints are about AI that can't solve the problem or blocks access to a person. An agent that answers fast, books appointments, and transfers to a human on the first request avoids the main issues callers reported. Recorded calls will tell you whether your setup is working.

Do customers leave reviews after talking to AI?

Rarely. The survey found people were almost seven times more likely to leave a review after a positive interaction with a person (55%) than with AI (8%). Send review requests after the appointment or after a good call with your team instead.